This gluten free sticky toffee pudding is the ultimate recipe for desert. Nobody is going to know that it’s gluten free and dairy free. It is moist, decadent and delicious.
This post contains Affiliate links. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
How the recipe came about & a bonfire night story…
The first time I made this recipe was for bonfire night.
The perfect excuse for a ‘special’ meal of roast chicken followed by a hot decadent sticky pudding.
It’s not easy to find a gluten free and dairy free sticky toffee pudding and consequently the kids had never had it before.
To say it was a success is an understatement! It flew out of the bowls at the speed of light, and of course, seconds were asked for.
The same success cannot be accredited to the fireworks display that we went to afterwards.
On a fabulous evening of no rain and barely a chill in the air, we got all dressed up after tea and headed up to a favourite local charity, Stallcombe House, for their annual spectacular bonfire and display.
Now, we have been going since the kids were 2 and 4, and each year, our youngest has hated it.
Each year he’s said “next year I will love fireworks” between screams and sobs with head thrust into my neck.
This year was slightly different. He said he didn’t want to go, until the last minute when he decided that he did.
Predictably, the minute the first firework shot into the sky and burst into shards of colour he started sobbing and asking to go to the car.
Five minutes later, our daughter, the one who has always loved the display, decided that she was going to be terrified too. So, after a slippery, muddy walk back to the car in the dark, we sat snuggled in the warm enjoying the fabulous display.
The morning after, ‘Sunshine’ announced that he “loved fireworks” and then proceeded to make our neighbours little boy cry by telling him that he had been to a display.
Anyway, story over and onto the recipe.
How do you make a gluten free sticky toffee pudding?
Sticky toffee pudding is much easier to make than you might think.
After placing the chopped dates into a bowl with boiling water and bicarbonate of soda you cream the butter (or margarine) with the sugar. Then add all the remaining ingredients including the soaked dates and water.
I use my Sage stand mixer to cream the butter/margarine and sugar together. It has fabulous scraping beaters meaning you don’t have to stop and scrape the mixture off the sides all the time. It also means you can set it going and get on with doing another job.
You can bake the sticky toffee pudding in whatever size and shape tin you like.
The first time I made it I used a rectangular tray like this one. However you could use a smaller deeper tray and you’ll get thicker slices (like those pictured here). Just cook for an additional 15 minutes or so.
How have you made this pudding healthier?
I always try to make my recipes healthier than the ‘standard’ recipe.
This one is no exception so I’ve recently updated it, cutting back on the amount of sugar. I’ve also switched brown sugar for coconut sugar (that I personally find has less of an impact on my blood sugar levels).
Fibre, found in wholegrain’s, is an important part of everyone’s diet and the gluten free diet is often lacking in it. That’s why I created my flour blend after finding nothing else like it on the market.
If you want to understand more about gluten free flour blends, what they are and why they are critical to your gluten free baking success then check out this article here.
And if you like this recipe then grab a free copy of my popular recipe book. It covers gluten free pastry, bread, pizza, Yorkshire puddings, scones, Victoria sponge, pancakes and gingerbread.
You’ll also get a weekly newsletter from me with recipe inspiration in. Of course you can unsubscribe to that at any time…
Make sure you Pin the recipe for gluten free sticky toffee pudding:
Gluten Free Sticky Toffee Pudding
- 175 g dates stoned and chopped
- 300 ml boiling water
- 1 tsp bicarbonate soda
- 85 g dairy-free margarine or butter if you're not dairy-free
- 100 g coconut sugar or soft brown sugar if you like
- 2 large eggs ideally organic
- 190 g Free From Fairy gluten free plain flour
- 2 tsp baking powder I use Dr Oetker
- 1 tsp vanilla extract
Toffee sauce ingredients
To make the pudding
Place the chopped dates and bicarbonate of soda in the boiling water and leave to soften for approx. 15-20 minutes
Cream (whisk) the butter and sugar together until the mixture is paler, using a stand mixer if you have one
Add the remaining ingredients, including the dates and whisk together until well mixed
Place in a greased cake tin, the size and shape depending on whether you want very deep slices or 'shallower' ones. See discussion above
Bake at 190 degrees or 170 degree fan oven for approx. 25 minutes. This is based on a 20cm x 30cm tin. The bake time will depend on the size of tin you use. If you are putting the mixture into a deeper tin then you will need to bake for longer. Test if it is cooked by poking the top...if it springs back, it is done! Or insert a skewer. It should come out clean.
- Whilst your pudding is cooking, make the toffee sauce...
To make the toffee sauce
Mix the cornflour with approx. 3tbsp milk in a small saucepan, making sure there are no lumps
Add the remaining ingredients and slowly bring to the boil, stirring frequently
Once boiling, turn the heat up so that you get quite big bubbles coming to the surface and keep stirring frequently for approx. 20 minutes or until the sauce becomes the consistency you require.
Remove from the heat and serve with your warm pudding and some dairy-free vanilla ice cream.
Nutrition data for guidance only